CASE DISCUSSION: THE FORGOTTEN WOMEN AND THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF THE UPGRADING OF LAND TENURE RIGHTS ACT OF 1991 – MANTSHABELLE MARY RAHUBE V HENDSRINE RAHUBE AND 6 OTHERS

On 26 September 2017, the Pretoria High Court (the Court) brought great relief to an elderly woman facing eviction by her brother from the house she had been living in and maintaining for over 32 years.
The Mantshabelle Mary Rahube v Hendsrine Rahube matter (Rahube) raised the constitutionality of section 2(1) of the Upgrading of Land Tenure Rights Act of 1991 (the Upgrading Act). The Upgrading Act provides for the upgrading and conversion of certain rights to property (afforded under apartheid) to ownership. The Court agreed with the applicant (Mrs Rahube) that despite its well-intended purpose, section 2(1) of the Upgrading Act, which automatically converts land tenure rights to ownership without any notification to occupants and other affected parties, is unconstitutional. The Court held it violates the constitutional right to equality by perpetuating discrimination based on gender and access to Courts by failing to provide a legal mechanism to dispute the entitlement.

It is vital that all citizens participate in the election of their representatives to guarantee government by the people under the Constitution – not only in Parliament but also in crucial institutions, such as the Commission for Gender Equality (CGE). The CGE is currently in the process of filling several vacancies and in the interests of public participation and representative democracy, the Centre for Constitutional Rights (the CFCR) will provide the public with more information about the CGE, the selection process and the prospective candidates.
The uThukela District Municipality (the Municipality) in KwaZulu-Natal Province has established a “Maidens Bursary” to fund higher education for young women. That is laudable. But, that is not all. Sixteen young women who are the beneficiaries of the scholarship, are reportedly examined regularly to ascertain their virginity. The bursary is conditioned upon their remaining virgins. This, happening in 2016, in a supposedly constitutional democracy.
Today, October 15, is the International Day of Rural Women as set by the United Nations. The day seeks to recognise the role of rural women in enhancing agricultural and rural development, improving food security and eradicating rural poverty. Indications, however, are that South Africa is far from this ideal.
“Is South Africa ready for a woman president?” – screams the occasional news headline. The same question was posed to the president of the women’s league of the governing party, and elicited the following response: while there had been advances in having women in leadership, the “time was not yet ripe to have a woman lead” the party, and by implication, the country. The same question was asked a year later – the treasurer-general of the same organisation responded, “everybody is ready for a woman leader”.
A woman becomes the subject of public ridicule over her choice of dress.
As we reflect on International Women’s Day – celebrated worldwide annually on 8 March – it is important to not only continue celebrating the achievements of women, but to continue to call for greater equality.
Every year from 25 November to 10 December – 16 days in total – the world comes together to advocate for a pandemic that affects millions of women and girls across the globe: domestic violence. The movement is called “16 Days of Activism against Gender Violence”. Governments, international organisations, non-governmental organisations (NGOs), civil society organisations, faith-based organisations and individuals rally together during this period to raise awareness about gender violence in their communities.